Why Izzy Tells His 1 Great Story

12019-bronx-98079

Third in an occasional series about clients with stories to tell

As five-year-old Izzy Silva waited with his mother for the light to turn green, he saw a car slowly approach on the left. Then he saw what looked like a stick appear.

Then he heard one loud gunshot. A man standing next to him staggered and fell. As his mother screamed and took off, Izzy went to the man, who was bleeding profusely.

The man indicated for him to press his hands where there was blood, and he did. “I looked at him. He looked at me and loosened his grip and then relaxed,” Izzy recounted years later. “His eyes seemed to fade. I wasn’t sure what was happening, but I knew it wasn’t good. Then he closed his eyes.

“That was my introduction to the harsh realities of the South Bronx. I still don’t know why I didn’t run.”

Even in the middle of the Bronx, Izzy came to know there was another way.

Some sixty-five years later, after he escaped and became a successful orthopedic surgeon, he’s telling this story to show other people that they, too, can overcome their origins. His book The Bronx Brothers: A Tale of Two Choices will be published next year.

Izzy’s life story is extreme. Your story may not be, but that’s okay. I still want to ask you: Why tell your story?

You tell it because the story does something for the reader. How dramatic the story is has nothing to do with it.

I saw that Izzy had four universal reasons for wanting to do this: it shows how choices affect outcomes, it lets the next person hear it, it remembers the dead, and it’s honest. These apply to your less-violent and quieter story, too.

Reason one: How choices affect outcomes

Izzy and David were products of where they grew up. They had the same parents, lived in the same apartment, faced the same neighborhood dangers, risks, and temptations, yet lived very different lives.

David joined the local gang, the Ghetto Brothers, robbed drug houses as a teenager and got addicted to heroin. One story stood out: David came by the house at 2 a.m. and while talking to his brother pushed Izzy’s books aside and threw a wad of money at him.

“You got to live for now,” David said. “I wanna enjoy life now while it’s here. I don’t wanna wait for the rewards.”

“You better start hitting books,” Izzy told him, “‘cause if you don’t hit books, you just gonna be a guy. By the time I’m thirty, I’m gonna be a millionaire. You gonna be pushing a snow cone cart or a hot dog cart on the street trying to make money.”

Years later, David realized it had come true: He was selling hot dogs in New York, and his brother was rich enough to own a boat.

Stories based on choices let readers see themselves. Your choices are your own, and the decisions you make, or didn’t make, work the same way.

What choice changed everything for you?

Reason two: The next person hears it

The book follows David’s realization that his brother was right and he should have followed his lead. In his forties and in jail for what would be the last time, David told the much-younger inmates about what life was really like in Rikers Island, and how important it is to straighten yourself out.

Later, as David’s son sat behind Izzy’s big desk, David told him, “You know what you gotta do to get to this point? You gotta follow what your uncle does, not me. Go to school, stay in school, and this is what you get. Go with the gangs, leave school, and you get me, and you don’t want to be like me. You want to be better.”

David wasn’t the only one who realized Izzy was right. In the last few years, another gang member found Izzy and told him he was the reason he beat his drug habit and turned his life around.

“I remember you studied hard, and you helped me out with school when I was flunking out of school and dropped out. You told me, ‘Stay in school. You can do it.’ I saw you studying. You’re an example for me. That’s what I did,” he told Izzy. “I made it through all the hardships I had because of you.”

One person can talk to only so many people, but a book keeps talking even after the reader puts it down. Who would you hand your book to?

Reason three: Remembering the dead

So many people in the neighborhood didn’t make it out alive. Two died of AIDS from needle use, two died of drug overdoses, four were shot, one was beaten to death, and one committed suicide. Most of the people Izzy grew up with never reached old age.

These people didn’t get to tell their stories, so Izzy did it. One gang member nicknamed Eddie Cat, David’s friend from third grade who robbed drug houses with him, was shot twelve times in a drive-by as David went into a store to get a drink. He died in David’s arms before reaching the hospital.

There was Miss Bob, a gay palm reader who died young. David protected from him abuse. Miss Bob correctly predicted Eddie Cat would die by gun. He read David’s palm but never told him what he saw except to say he would live a long time, though not everyone around him would.

Then Miss Bob told David, “Don’t ever let anybody else read your palm.”

If your story includes people who are gone or were overlooked, writing it is a good way of keeping them alive.

Which people do you want to memorialize?

Reason four: An honest accounting

Izzy survived, but he still made major mistakes along the way and admitted to them.

He learned karate and, after walking a guy home who had been harassing Izzy’s sister, used it once to disarm the guy who now wielded a billy club, but then Izzy took the club and hit his would-be attacker in the head—in front of the guy’s mother. 

The mother let out blood-curdling screams. “You killed him! You killed him!”

It wasn’t true, but Izzy didn’t know that at the time. He ran and hid, thinking his life was over. When the police arrived, he came out from hiding to surrender and was taken to the mother for identification.

“Yeah, that’s him, Officer,” she said with tears in her eyes, “but it was my son that attacked him first. He said he was bringing him in to protect him from the other guys in the street. Let him go.”

A ghostwriter’s job is to ask the questions that get the honest, unfiltered, and uncensored version of the story, not the one that makes the author look the best. When Izzy told me about the billy club story, I was shocked because he had been such a model kid.

“Wow!” I said.

“I wasn’t perfect,” he said simply.

Are you ready to unmask yourself?

Your story won’t look like Izzy’s, and it shouldn’t. It will stand on its own, but ask yourself these questions: Who is your story for? What do you want them to understand? What do you want them to do differently? Who else is in your story that deserves to be mentioned? Are you ready to unmask yourself for your audience?

Everyone has a story. Are you ready to tell yours?

If you or someone you know is thinking about a book and wants to talk, take a look at some of my other posts on ghostwriting at https://leebarnathan.com/blog/ or reach out directly to set up a conversation.

Let's Start A New Project Together

Contact me and we can explore how a ghostwriter or editor can benefit you.