Discretion: 1 Greatly Needed Skill

geralt-yes-5082976

In discussing discretion, what would you tell a ghostwriter that you wouldn’t tell your best friend?

Maybe it was that they never loved their spouse or their children. Maybe it was the affair they had, the abuse they suffered, or the shame they have carried for so many years.

Or maybe it was what two interview subjects once told me about my client: They were deeply hurt that their friend (my client) believed her psychopath boyfriend over them.

“I was really sad about it,” one told me. “I had twins, and she didn’t know about them.” 

“We wanted to shake her and say, “You’re not stupid. Get away from this idiot!’” the other said. “She was the perfect victim.”

When having a memoir ghostwritten, deeply personal things get revealed. They might embarrass or involve other people. They might have been buried for decades.

But they need to come out. A ghostwriter can’t tell the real story without all the details, so the ghostwriter needs to show discretion.

This creates an unusual relationship: The person helping you tell your story may come to know you better than your friends. So, when considering a ghostwriter, ask, “Can I trust this person with what I’m going to tell them?”

Discretion is more than just keeping a secret

Every ghostwriter must master discretion. It’s more than just promising not to repeat something. The best ghostwriters know what information needs to go in the book—and what doesn’t. They know how to sensitively broach a subject, when to stop asking questions, and how to recognize when information should not be dinner-party conversation.

When evaluating a ghostwriter, you want someone who understands what can be said and what shouldn’t.

There’s a wide variety of possible trouble spots to consider. A memoir might cover childhood traumas, family dysfunction, infidelity, divorce, death, addiction, financial problems, relationships gone bad, actions you might regret, the feelings over what someone else did to you, and secrets you’ve kept for much of your life.

Not only that, but a memoir rarely contains only the author’s life. Many others appear: rivals, parents, friends, children, spouses (former and current), business associates, partners, colleagues, teachers, neighbors, and distant family.

Not all of these details or people need to go in your finished book. However, you might have to tell your ghostwriter so he or she can understand your story, even if the reader never reads it. That’s one example of discretion.

I have a client who tells it like it is, saying things such as This guy is a hanger-on, this guy is selfish, this woman is emotionally unstable. Much of the details he gives me won’t appear in the finished manuscript because they aren’t relevant. 

For example, he described a woman this way: “I considered her a creepy bottom-feeder and a bar hag. She smoked cigarettes, which I hate, and slept around. In the looks department, she was no better than a six.” Much of this doesn’t need to go in because her actions don’t reflect this description.

Appearing vs. cutting

This is an important distinction when looking to hire a ghostwriter. Not everything you say goes in the book. Some of it is only so the ghostwriter understands a person, a relationship, or a motivation. Your ghostwriter isn’t entitled to include everything just because he or she learned it. You want to make sure you hire a ghostwriter who respects the difference between understanding and including, between background and specifics. 

A good book editor in Chicago should help you think through what needs to be identified and what can remain anonymous, what needs to be verified, and what could harm someone if it were to be included in the book.

Discretion isn’t passive. Your ghostwriter needs to look out for you by raising privacy issues before you think to do so.

This begins with the earliest interviews. A good interviewer is curious, but there need to be boundaries lest it moves into exploitation. Therefore, look for ghostwriters who understand when a question is necessary to understand the story and when it’s only to satisfy the ghostwriter’s curiosity.

I remember one client talking to me about her sex life. I didn’t think we needed to go there because it had nothing to do with her relationship with her husband. It’s understood that married people have sex, I told her. We needed no specifics.

The point is to hire a ghostwriter who can get the information from you to tell your story in the most truthful, meaningful, and compelling way.

Discretion and honesty are not opposites. A discreet ghostwriter shouldn’t agree to put in everything you want. You should want a ghostwriter who says, “We don’t need that,” “I need to verify that,” “This could be problematic for you (or someone else),” and “Are you sure you want this in your book?”

When choosing a ghostwriter, look for someone whose discretion includes telling you what you don’t want to hear.

What you can do

Before hiring a ghostwriter, ask these questions:

• “How do you handle confidential information?”

• “Who else will have access to my interviews and materials?”

• “Do you use subcontractors, editors, researchers, or AI tools in your process?”

• “How do you handle information that I don’t want included in the book?”

• “What happens to my recordings, notes, and documents when the project ends?”

• “Have you ever encountered information you believed shouldn’t be included? How did you handle it?”

Also, pay attention to how your prospective ghostwriter talks about previous clients. What details are revealed, and how cavalierly? When telling stories, does the ghostwriter say things that are at the client’s expense? What do they disclose about those past clients, and was that information obviously given to them privately? Do they say the client’s real name, and was that really necessary? Do they seem to enjoy telling you things that you think are none of your business?

If the prospective ghostwriter tells you secrets just to impress you, steer clear because you can imagine what will happen with the info you tell. You’ll want a ghostwriter to show they know how to demonstrate experience without violating privacy or confidentiality.

In the end, discretion is about trust. You’re hiring someone who you will reveal deep, dark, private secrets about you. That requires vulnerability, so make sure you trust your ghostwriter will have the proper discretion to deal with that information properly.

That way, you’ll safely trust them with the stuff even your best friends won’t know until they read it.

If you’re thinking about a book and and looking for a ghostwriter in Chicago, take a look at some of my other posts on ghostwriting at https://leebarnathan.com/blog/ or reach out directly to set up a conversation.

Let's Start A New Project Together

Contact me and we can explore how a ghostwriter or editor can benefit you.